I'm not sure if we've established the song names, so I'll take the liberty to post them:
(in order of appearance)
Horrible Theme, 9 sec, plays during the credits for acts 1/2/3
My Freeze Ray, 1 min 54 sec, laundry song. Why does everyone call this Laundry Day? I know that's the first line and the song is sung in a laundromat, but it's about his freeze ray!
Bad Horse Chorus, 35 sec, sung while DH opens his letter from Bad Horse
Caring Hands, 36 sec, sung while Penny hands out flyers
A Man's Gotta Do, 2 min 20 sec, introduces Captain Hammer, continues until the end of Act 1
My Eyes, 2 min 47 sec, opening for Act 2. I can see why this is titled My Eyes, as both DH and Penny sing multiple times "I cannot believe my eyes" and usually they sing it at the same time. The song is about life from their point of view.
Bad Horse Chorus (Reprise), 21 sec, sung after DH reveals that his freeze ray "needs work"
Penny's Song, 1 min 23 sec, sung in the laundromat after DH says, "Not to me." (continuing from Penny/DH's conversation: everything happens/ don't say for reasons/ no, just everything happens/ not to me
Brand New Day, 1 min 49 sec, MY FAVORITE!!!!!, sung after Captain Hammer tells DH that he's not the hammer, the hammer is his ***** and he and Penny leave, closing for Act 2
So They Say, 2 min 12 sec, opening for Act 3
Everyone's A Hero, 2 min 45 sec, Captain Hammer's big speech after he says he doesn't need "tiny cue cards"
Slipping, 2 min 5 sec, sung after DH zaps Captain Hammer with his Freeze Ray
Everything You Ever, 3 min 35 sec, longest song, sung when Penny is injured by the death ray's explosion
Horrible Credits, 2 min 12 sec, played while credits roll
14 songs total. I don't know the songs for Commentary! The Musical